• There has been a recent cluster of spammers accessing BARFer accounts and posting spam. To safeguard your account, please consider changing your password. It would be even better to take the additional step of enabling 2 Factor Authentication (2FA) on your BARF account. Read more here.

Daily carry knife?

Keep the Leek.

The pronounced recurve on the Chive's blade will complicate stropping and sharpening. The little Chive may appear more like a friendly "office knife," but if its small size makes you fumble around with it when you handle it, that office-friendly appearance is negated by looking like you may have an accident. Keep the one that you can easily handle and sharpen.

Plus, you may find instances where you want that extra blade length. 1.5" is probably more than enough for 90% of tasks, but if you end up having to break down boxes or cut food, you'll want that extra length. I think 3-3.5" is the ideal EDC size.

Wow, that lines up perfectly with what I was going to say. :thumbup
 
Wow, that lines up perfectly with what I was going to say. :thumbup

And what I was thinking. Funny, I dropped the Chive on my living room floor (About 2.5 feet) and it popped open. Not a good sign.

Thanks guys. It's going back.
 
FWIW, I'm thinking about a Leek. To me it boils down to how you'll use the tool and what other tools you'll have handy.
 
And what I was thinking. Funny, I dropped the Chive on my living room floor (About 2.5 feet) and it popped open. Not a good sign.

Thanks guys. It's going back.

Another drawback of assisted opening. If the Leek wasn't AO, I'd have bought one many years ago.
 
I've never had an AO knife open like that before and I have at least 3.
 
BTW. I just checked Amazon Deals today and the Leek is $27!!!
 
Last edited:
Ah, I posted in the other thread, but I'll post here too. Look into a Scallion. It's right between the Leek and the Chive in size.
 
Another drawback of assisted opening. If the Leek wasn't AO, I'd have bought one many years ago.

I've used assisted opening knives for years and haven't experienced any of the drawbacks you've mentioned. They've all been dead reliable and I've had no misfires. Three of mine have safeties, though I don't normally engage them.
 
It's actually true...

Sale ends in just under 2 hours.

Oh, I believed him. I was thinking on the way to work this morning that I should have waited for "Cyber Monday" but I had to get a B-Day present on order for my wife and just added it to my cart.
 
OK, maybe it's not fair to expect that a good quality AO would typically have problems like that, but here's a situation with a Kershaw malfunctioning, and that's a quality knife. The POS folders that you get at tobacco shops and flea markets WILL open on their own. It's happened to me with one of those smoke shop specials, luckily it was a tip up carry.
 
OK, maybe it's not fair to expect that a good quality AO would typically have problems like that, but here's a situation with a Kershaw malfunctioning, and that's a quality knife. The POS folders that you get at tobacco shops and flea markets WILL open on their own. It's happened to me with one of those smoke shop specials, luckily it was a tip up carry.

I'd say the Kershaw is vulnerable to opening if dropped the wrong way, but they need to be manually opened quite a bit for the spring to take over. Personally, I don't consider opening when dropped to be a big deal. When carried properly, the edge of the pocket will keep the blade from opening.
 
I'd say the Kershaw is vulnerable to opening if dropped the wrong way, but they need to be manually opened quite a bit for the spring to take over. Personally, I don't consider opening when dropped to be a big deal. When carried properly, the edge of the pocket will keep the blade from opening.

They also have a blade lock if one is worried about unintended opening.

My Kershaw has never opened on it's own, and I've dropped it a bunch of times.
 
They also have a blade lock if one is worried about unintended opening.

My Kershaw has never opened on it's own, and I've dropped it a bunch of times.

:laughing When I opened the first box I got the knife out and was like "WTF? It won't open" then I found the lock. :blush I don't often read instructions. It's a nice feature though.

I may have touched the AO on the back of the Chive when I dropped it. :dunno
 
FWIW my Kershaw opens about half of the time if I drop it to the floor for some strange reason.

I'm not really worried about that though 'cause my dropping it *is* a strange thing.
 
Lot of ridiculous knives in this thread, most purchased only to satisfy the owners' fantasies rather than the realities of knife usage.

I have a few small Moras lying around that I carry. Most recently the Mora Basic Wood Carving knife. ~3" blade, absurdly sharp great swedish high carbon steel with a Scandi grind which is easy to keep shaving sharp.

DSCN9491.jpg


Barely over $10 - Mora knives are probably the best bang for the buck in knives, period. Why bother with more? Short from batoning a tree, which is a STUPID use of a knife, it'll do anything you want.
 
My Gerber will open about half the time when it is dropped w/o safety engaged. Seems when it lands on its back side on hard surface it opened every time. Still my favorite everyday carry.

It's a knife, handle with care.
 
Moras are great knives, I got one for my gf to use a camp knife. I want the black Bushcrafter model for myself, extremely useful for pretty much any task, great slicers and strong (keep em oiled though). I wouldn't baton with them either but thats what my Rat 7 is for.

Theyre fuckin sharp out of the box, I cut the shit out of myself the other weekend when it slipped and barely tapped my finger. Too bad you can't *legally* carry a fixed knife here in CA unless its open carry, a small one would be a fantastic neck or boot knife.

I've used assisted opening knives for years and haven't experienced any of the drawbacks you've mentioned. They've all been dead reliable and I've had no misfires. Three of mine have safeties, though I don't normally engage them.
The Kershaw assisted opening knives are always wanting to blow open, I've had a couple and you have to be careful with them especially once you take off that annoying safety. I've had other AO knives that didn't do that.
 
Last edited:
The Kershaw assisted opening knives are always wanting to blow open, I've had a couple and you have to be careful with them especially once you take off that annoying safety. I've had other AO knives that didn't do that.

I have a Kershaw that never had an annoying safety (I haven't seen one) and never tries to blow open. I have a couple of older Bucks that had little safeties, as well as a SOG Trident that has a safety in the handle.

That SOG ended up being the knife I carried in a winter crossing of the Sierra on skis. Pretty useful blade shape, light weight and no chance of accidental opening.
 
Been rocking the Sypderco Smock for 6 months now. Amazing EDC with the easiest deployment I’ve ever seen.

The squared off corner flick is great for rapid deployment and not having your finger near sharp moving parts.
 

Attachments

  • 7407779A-1A9F-427E-9763-1FA5CC9A8879.png
    7407779A-1A9F-427E-9763-1FA5CC9A8879.png
    193.2 KB · Views: 122
Back
Top